NYC is a small world, so running into an old high school friend shouldn't be this shocking.
Nick surprises Tim and Andrea while they are on a date.
Tim and Andrea go on a double date with their friend Katie and her new boyfriend.
Nick and Tim put their differences aside.
Nick and Tim meet some of Katie's Old Friends at her birthday party and not everyone gets along.
Andrea and Katie havea girl's night out only to be surprised in more ways than one when Nick and Tim arrive.

Whether your married or recently in love, introductions can be tricky.

Guest Starring: Mary Elizabeth Ellis Day (It's Always Sunny in Philidalphia)